| Platinum | Bird's Aphrodisiac Oyster Shack |
| Gold | New Orleans Seafood |
| Silver | Horizons Bar and Grille |
| Bronze | Wharf Casual Seafood |
| Top Pick | Crafty Crab |
| Top Pick | Shell Oyster Bar |
| Top Pick | Tally Fish House & Oyster Bar |
| Top Pick | Wharf Express |
| Bella Bella | |
| The Edison |